Short Attention Span Review™
What makes great science fiction writers "great" is the ability to capture a great concept while telling a compelling story. I could just as easily have read an article in a scientific journal and gleaned as much information on the Ringworld concept as I did from this novel . . . sans forgettable characters and story.
Before there was Halo, there was Ringworld by Larry Niven. And before Ringworld, there were…well…Dyson Spheres.
I recently finished Larry Niven’s seminal work after many years of procrastination (I’m good at it). I use the world “seminal” because he’s managed to milk this brilliant idea into a quite boring 4 book series despite the effort put forth in this award winning classic.
Ringworld won Hugo and Nebula awards in 1970. I can’t conceive how he won based on storytelling. I can only speculate that he won the awards based on the speculative concept.
Conceptually Ringworld introduces a great idea to the genre: a modifed Dyson Sphere. The “ringworld” is a world large enough to invoke a sense of adventure and a tapestry rich enough to paint innumerable tales. Unfortunately this isn’t one of them…
In this novel Niven possesses a complete lack of narrative storytelling. Descriptive passages are muddled and lacking. Dialogue is almost sophomoric. And the story itself borders on boring and tedious…not unlike the feelings Louis Wu has towards his own life at the beginning of the book. I never got the sense of “awe” I should have felt while reading about these characters traversing a small infinitesimal sliver of the Ringworld after their ship crashes. I was completely apathetic to the characters…I didn’t care one way or another what happened to them. This removes one of the trifectas of storytelling right out of the work: characters.
Another thing that soured me about the book was the pretentious text on the rear cover of the book I own:
“I myself have dreamed up a structure intermediate between Dyson spheres and planets. Build a ring 93 million miles in radius — one Earth orbit– around the sun. If we have the mass of Jupiter to work with, and if we make it a thousand miles wide, we get a thickness of about a thousand feet for the base.
And it has advantages. The Ringworld will be much sturdier than a Dyson sphere. We can spin it on its axis for gravity. A rotation speed of 770 m/s will give us a gravity of one Earth normal. We wouldn’t even need to roof it over. Place walls one thousand miles high at each edge, facing the sun. Very little air will leak over the edges.
Lord knows the thing is roomy enough. With three million times the surface area of the Earth, it will be some time before anyone complains of the crowding.”
This quote gets to the very problem with Ringworld. This has everything to do with the technobabble and very little to do with presenting a great work of speculative fiction that both informs and entertains.
So, a brief summary of Ringworld: Bored protagonist seeks adventure. Goes on adventure. Finds astounding Ringworld (with help). Has very boring adventure (flying around, sleeping, some flowers, sex, yawn). The end.
The execution of Ringworld reminds me of how id Software works. They are excellent at creating gaming technology (namely 3D engine tech), but are horrible at implementation (at least in my opinion), producing extremely boring games. Niven is great at concepts, terrible at execution…at least in this case.
Mediocre books like this seem to garner a rabid fan base who can see no wrong in the work…similar to Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card. An okay book, but completely simplistic in concept and theme. If you try to publicly criticize books of this caliber one is usually inundated with the wrath of countless fans who vehemently disagree with your assessment.
What makes great science fiction writers “great” is the ability to capture a great concept while telling a compelling story. If a writer can’t do both why should I read their works of fiction? I could just as easily have read an article in a scientific journal and gleaned as much information on the Ringworld concept as I did from this novel . . . sans forgettable characters and story.
Ringworld by Larry Niven
Genre: Science Fiction
– As entertainment.
– For speculative concept.